Musk Butterfly by By Kilian bottle
By Kilian

Musk Butterfly

3.4/5 · 171 votes Feminine 2021
Main accords
Where to buy
Love Musk Butterfly?
Save it to your favourites and discover similar scents in the Nardinum app.
Get the app

Fragrance notes

Top notes
Heart notes
Base notes

Character

Longevity3.1/5
Sillage2.5/5
Day100
Night46
Spring93
Summer76
Fall72
Winter67
Our take

It opens with a fizzy, almost glassy burst of aldehydes, sharp enough to cut through the soapy shimmer of Turkish and Damask roses. Litchi adds a watery, candied tartness that keeps the florals from turning stodgy, while geranium nudges them toward a green, slightly metallic edge. Then the violet and violet leaf arrive, and the whole composition softens into something that feels like a powder compact left open on a damp garden bench, sweet and faintly mineral. The drydown is where the trouble starts: ambrette gives a clean, fuzzy musk that could have been lovely, but the sandalwood and oud here are whisper-thin and synthetic, collapsing into a pale, woody haze that barely clings to skin.

Musk Butterfly is a fragrance caught between two ambitions. It wants to be a shimmering, aldehydic floral like a 1920s debutante, but it also wants to be a modern, sheer skin scent. The result is a butterfly whose wings are damp: pretty at first glance, but it can’t quite lift off. Longevity sits at a disappointing 3.06 out of 5, and sillage is a barely-there 2.45, meaning you’ll be reapplying every two hours and no one will notice unless they’re breathing down your neck. It’s best worn on a dewy spring morning when you want to smell like you just stepped out of a cloud, not a room.

Who should reach for it? If you adore powdery violets and shy musks, if you want a fragrance that whispers rather than speaks, this is your cup of iced lychee tea. Who should skip it? Anyone who expects projection, longevity, or a trace of the oud that’s listed on the pyramid. This is a ghost of a perfume, lovely for an intimate brunch or a solo walk through a blooming park, but it vanishes before dessert arrives. 🦋

Smells similar

Built from the same materials — ranked by how unusual the shared notes are, not by how many.

More from By Kilian

All By Kilian →